Q4 2019 RatesLast Updated Jan 20 2020
QUARTERLY TRACKING TABLE | RETAIL POWER AND GAS RATES

regulation data

Start of ProceedingDate of PublicationCompanyParent CompanyAgencyServiceStatePlan NameStatusDocket ProceedingEnerknol Customizable MonitorCategorySub CategoryDescriptionSummaryApplication FilingRequested ROE/Authorized ROERequested ROERequested ROE TitleRelevant Paragraph for Requested ROEAuthorized ROEDocument with Authorized ROEDate of Filing Authorized ROEKey FilingsKey Filing DateAnalyst Coverage AnnouncementsNotes
Nov 22 2019Xcel Energy Inc.Southwest Public Service Co.ElectricMinnesotaOpenM-19-732Xcel_Energy_Minnesota_PUC_Elec_Nov_2019_[M-19-732]Application of Southwestern Public Service Co. for Authority to Change Rates9.06%

“we have calculated the RES Rider revenue requirementsusing a return on equity (ROE) of 9.06%”

Nov 1 2019Xcel Energy Inc.Southwest Public Service Co.ElectricMinnesotaOpenGR-19-564Dakota_Electric--Minnesota_PUC--Elec--Sep_2019--[GR-19-564]Northern States Power Company, doing business as Xcel Energy, is planning to file its next electric rate case on November 1, 2019 in the above-noted docket.10.20%

It is my view that an ROE of 10.20 percent is reasonable and would fairly balance the interests of customers and shareholders.

Oct 18 2019Powder River Energy CorporationTouchstone Energy CooperativesElectricWyomingOpen15372Powder_River_Energy_Wyoming_PSC_Elec_Oct_2019_[15372]Powder River Energy Corporation ("PRECorp") hereby submits its Application for Authority for a General Rate Increase ("Application") to the Wyoming Public Service CommissionN/A

N/A

Oct 1 2019Virginia Electric and Power Co.Dominion Energy Inc.ElectricVirginiaOpenPUR-2019-00159Virginia_Electric_and_Power--Virginia_SCC--Elec--Oct_2019--[PUR-2019-00159]Application for revision of rate adjustment10.75%

The Company is proposing the use of a return on common equity (“ROE”) of 10.75% in this proceeding.

Oct 1 2019Arizona Public Service Co.Pinnacle West Capital Corp.ElectricArizonaOpenE-01345A-19-0236Arizona_Public_Service--Arizona_CC--Elec-Oct_2019--[E-01345A-19-0236]Notice of Intent to File Rate Case10.15%

As discussed by APS witness Ann E. Bulkley, who is Senior Vice President,Concentric Energy Advisors, Inc., APS proposes a return on equity of l0.l5%, which isat the lower end of the recommended range.

Sep 30 2019Duke Energy Progress LLCDuke Energy Corp.ElectricNorth CarolinaOpenE-2 SUB 1219Duke_Energy_Progress--North_Carolina_UC--Elec--Sep_2019--[E-2 SUB 1219]Notice of intent to file a general rate application10.30%

In this area, Witness Karl Newlin discusses how the Company has proposed a return on equity of 10.3% as a rate impact mitigation measure

Sep 19 2019Dakota Electric AssociationDakota Electric AssociationElectricMinnesotaOpenGR-19-478Dakota_Electric--Minnesota_PUC--Elec--Sep_2019--[GR-19-478]Dakota Electric Association Initial FillingN/A

The calculation for determiningthe 4.14 percent return on equity; also shows the calculation of DEA’s 5.73 percent proposed ROR on rate base.

Aug 30 2019Southern California Edison Co.Edison InternationalElectricCaliforniaOpenA1908013Southern_California_Edison--California_PUC--Elec--Aug_2019--[A1908013]Application For Authority To Increase Authorized Revenues For Electric Service In 2021TBD

N/A

Aug 21 2019Northern Indiana Public Service Co.NiSource Inc.ElectricIndianaOpen44733 - TDSIC 6NIPSCO--Indiana_IURC--Elec--Aug_2019--[44733 - TDSIC 6]Northern Indiana Public Service Co. PetitionTBD

N/A

Aug 20 2019Union Electric Company d/b/a Ameren MissouriAmeren Corp.ElectricMissouriOpenET-2020-0042Union_Electric--Missouri_PSC--Elec--Aug_2019--[ET-2020-0042]Notice of Intended Case FilingTBD

N/A

Aug 8 2019Xcel Energy Inc.Southwest Public Service Co.ElectricTexasOpen49831Southwestern_Public_Service--TX_PUC--Elec--Aug_2019--[49831]Application of Southwestern Public Service Co. for Authority to Change Rates10.35%

The requested base rate increase includes a rate of return of 7.62%, which is composed of an equity ratio of 54.65%, a rate of return on common equity of 10.35%, and a cost of debt of 4.33%.

Aug 1 2019Duke Energy Kentucky Inc.Duke Energy Corp.ElectricKentuckyOpen2019-00271Duke_Energy--Kentucky_PSC--Elec--Aug_2019--[2019-00271]Notice of Intent to File an Application for An Adjustment of the Electric Rates, Approval of New Tariffs, Approval of Accounting Practices9.80%

Duke Kentucky is requesting an increase in its ROE from 9. 725 percent, as authorized in Case No. 2017-00321, to 9.800 percent

Aug 1 2019Northern Indiana Public Service Co.NiSource Inc.ElectricIndianaOpen42150 - ECR 34NIPSCO--Indiana_IURC--Elec--Aug_2019--[42150 - ECR 34]Northern Indiana Public Service Co. - Electric - petitionTBD

N/A

Aug 1 2019Fishers Island Electric Corp.Fishers Island Utility Co.ElectricNew YorkOpen19-E-0525Fishers_Island_Electric--New_York_PSC--Elec--Aug_2019--[19-E-0525]Fishers Island Electric Corp Rate Case ApplicationN/A

N/A

Jul 12 2019Kentucky Utilities Co.Old Dominion Power Co.ElectricVirginiaOpenPUR-2019-00060Kentucky_Utilities--Virginia_SCC--Elec--April_2019--[PUR-2019-00060]Kentucky Utilities Company d/b/a Old Dominion Power Company - Application for an Adjustment of Electric Base Rates10.50%

The Company’s proposed revenue requirement reflects an earned rate of return on rate11 base of 7.57%, based on a return on equity of 10.50% and an actual capital structure as of December 31,2018

Jul 2 2019Duke Energy Indiana LLCDuke Energy CorporationElectricIndianaOpen45253 - NONEDuke_Energy--Indiana_IURC--Elec--July_2019--[45253 - NONE]Duke Energy Indiana, LLC - PETITION10.40%

The rate of return includes the proposed return on equity of 10.4%

Jul 3 2019Ameren MissouriUnion Electric Co.ElectricMissouriOpenER-2019-0335Ameren_Missouri--Missouri_PSC--Elec--July_2019--[ER-2019-0335]Complete submission filing9.95%

The rate request is based on a 9.95% return on common equity

Jul 1 2019Southwestern Public Service Co.Xcel Energy Inc.ElectricNew MexicoOpen19-00170-UTSouthwestern_Public_Service_Company--New_Mexico_PRC--Elec--July_2019--[19-00170-UT]SPS Application for authority to change rates10.35%

a return on common equity of 10.35 percent

Jun 14 2019Sierra Pacific Power Co.NV EnergyElectricNevadaOpen19-06002Sierra_Pacific_Power--Nevada_PUC--Elec--June_2019--[19-06002]Notice of Application issued.9.50%

The signatories agree that the stated return on equity for Sierra’s electric operations will be set at 9.5 percent and any earnings in excess of 9.7 percent shall be shared equally between Sierra and its customers.

Jun 6 2019DTE Electric Co.DTE Energy Co.ElectricMichiganOpenU-20561DTE_Electric_Co--Michigan_PSC--Elec--June_2019--[U-20561]DTE Electric Companys Application10.50%

DTE Electric is requesting a return on equity of 10.5% with an overall rate of return of 5.73% after tax , 7.15% pre-tax.

May 30 2019Potomac Electric Power Co.Exelon Corp.ElectricWashingtonOpenFC1156Potomac_Electric_Power_Company--Washington_DC_PSC--Elec--May_2019--[FC1156]Pepco's Application for Authority to Implement a Multiyear Rate Plan for Electric Distribution Services in DC.10.30%

The revenue requirement is $88.6 million based on a return on equity of 10.3%.

May 29 2019The Empire District Electric Co.The Empire District Electric Co.ElectricMissouriOpenER-2019-0374The_Empire_District_Electric_Company--Missouri_PSC--May_2019--[ER-2019-0374]N/A9.95%

Based on 18the quantitative and qualitative analyses discussed throughout my Direct Testimony, and 19taking into consideration the Commission’s decisions in prior proceedings, I proposean 20ROE of 9.95percent.

May 20 2019Rochester Gas and Electric Corp.Iberdrola SAElectricNew YorkOpen19-E-0380Rochester_Gas_and_Electric_Corporation--New_York_PSC--Elec--May_2019--[19-G-0380]Revenue Requirements Panel Testimony -Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation-19-E-03809.50%

The 11 Companies are requesting Delivery revenues to be based on a 9.50% return on equity 12 (“ROE”) and 50% equity ratio.

May 20 2019New York State Electric & Gas CorporationIberdrola SAElectricNew YorkOpen19-E-0378New_York_State_Electric_&_Gas_Corporation--New_York_PSC--Elec--May_2019--[19-E-0378]Policy Panel Testimony -New York State Electric & Gas Corporation9.50%

The Companies are proposing an ROE of 9.5% and a 50% equity ratio

May 20 2019Public Service Co. of ColoradoXcel Energy Inc.ElectricColoradoOpen19AL-0268EPublic_Service_Company--Colorado_PUC--Elec--May_2019--[19AL-0268E]Testimony10.35%

This is based on 8the proposed return on equity (“ROE”) of 10.35 percen

May 14 2019Indiana Michigan Power Co.American Electric Power Co.ElectricIndianaOpen45235 - NONEIndiana_Michigan_Power_Company--Indiana_IURC--Elec--May_2019--[45235-NONE]Indiana Michigan Power Company - Petitioner's Submission of Administrative Notice9.95%

As a compromise of the Settling Parties’ positions, I&M’s ROE will be 9.95%, which reduces I&M’s test year revenue deficiency by $13 .1 million.

OPEN (new)
May 10 2019Indiana Michigan Power Co.American Electric Power Co.ElectricMichiganOpenU-20359Indiana_Michigan_Power_Company--Michigan_PSC--Elec--May_2019--[U-20359]Indiana Michigan Power Company's Filing Announcement10.50%

Indiana Michigan Power Company’s(I&M)June 24, 2019applicationwhich seeks Commission approval to: 1)adjust its retail rates and charges for electric service to provide additional revenue of approximately $58.8 million annually for the 12-month test year ending December 21, 2020; 2) adjust existing retail electric rates to produce a return on common equity of 10.5%;

OPEN (Pre-hearing stage)
May 1 2019AEP Texas Inc.American Electric Power Co.ElectricTexasOpen49494AEP_Texas--Texas_PUC--Elec--May_2019--[49494]Application of AEP Texas for Authority to Change Rates10.50%

AEP Texas’s requested return on equity is 10.5%

OPEN (Responses)
Apr 30 2019Avista UtilitiesAvista Corp.ElectricWashingtonOpenUE-190334Avista_Utilities--Washington_UTC--Elec--April_2019--[UE-190334]Testimony9.90%

As reflected in the testimony of MarkT. Thies, Avista is requesting a fair ROE 3 of 9.9 percent, which is well below the 10.4 percent midpoint of my 4 recommended range.

Apr 5 2019CenterPoint Energy Houston Electric LLCCenterPoint Energy Inc.ElectricTexasOpen49421CenterPoint_Energy_Texas_PUC--Elec--April_2019--[49421]CenterPoint Energy Houston Electric LLC application for authority to change rates10.40%

CenterPoint’s requested return on equity is 10.4%

OPEN (Request for information)
Mar 22 2019Public Service Company of New HampshireEversource EnergyElectricNew HampshireOpenDE 19-057Public_Service_of_New_Hampshire--Elec--New_Hampshire_PUC--March_2019--[DE 19-057]Eversource Energy Notice of Intent to File Permanent Rate Schedules10.40%

It is myview that an ROE of 10.40 would fairly balance the interests of customers and shareholders

N/ANo mention of proposed or requested ROE or any of the variations of the term
Mar 1 2019Interstate Power & Light Co.Alliant Energy Corp.ElectricIowaOpenRPU-2019-0001Interstate_Power_Light--Iowa_UB--Elec--March_2019--[RPU-2019-0001]Application for Increase in Electric Rates - Testimony9.80%

It is my opinion that a fair, reasonable, and sufficient ROE for IPL’s electric utility operations inthe Stateof Iowa is 9.8%

OPEN (Pre-hearing stage)
Feb 15 2019Narragansett Electric Co.National GridElectricRhode IslandOpen4930Naragansett_Electric--Rhode_Island_PUC--Elec--Feb_2019--[4930]Narragansett Electric Co. d/b/a National Grid - 2019 Electric Retail Rate FilingN/A

Common Equity Return 5.99% (displayed in a table)

OPEN (responses)
Jan 15 2019Potomac Electric Power Co.Exelon Corp.ElectricMarylandOpen9602Potomac_Electric--Maryland_PSC--Elec--Jan_2019--[9602]Potomac Electric Power Company - Application for Adjustments to its Retail Rates for the Distibution of Electric Energy10.30%0.103

the Company is requesting a $29.9million increase in base distribution revenue based on a ROE of 10.30%

OPEN (Briefing stage)
Nov 13 2019New Jersey Natural Gas CompanyNew Jersey ResourcesNatural GasNew JerseyOpenGR19030420GR18101096New_Jersey_Natural_Gas_Corporation_PSC_NG_Nov_2019_[GR19030420]Application of New Jersey Natural Gas Co. for Authority to change rates10.88%

NJNG also requested a return on equity of 10.875%

Nov 8 2019Eversource EnergyNSTAR Gas CompanyNatural GasMassachusettsOpen19-120Eversource_Energy_Massachusetts_DPU_NG_Nov_2019_[19-120]Application of Eversource Energy for Authority to change rates10.45%

“reflecting a return on equity (“ROE”) of 10.45 percent.”

Oct 28 2019CenterPoint Energy Minnesota GasUtility Holding LLCNatural GasMinnesotaOpenGR-19-524CenterPoint_Energy_Minnesota_PUC--NG--Oct_2019--[GR-19-524]General Rate Petition and Required Filing Information9.21%

The return on equity for the interim rate proposal is 9.21%, which is consistent with the recommended return identified in Commission Staff briefing papers in CenterPoint Energy’s most recent rate proceeding

Oct 18 2019DTE Gas CompanyDTE Energy Co.Natural GasMichiganOpenU-20642DTE_Gas_Company_Michigan_PSC_NG_Oct_2019_[U-20642]DTE Gas Companys Filling Announcement10.50%

The Company is requesting a Return on Equity of 10.5%, capital structure of 48% debt and 52% equity, and an annual inflation factor of 2.9% for 2019, 2020 and 2021.

Oct 8 2019Dominion Energy South CarolinaDominion Energy Inc.Natural GasSouth CarolinaOpen2019-6-GDominion_Energy--South_Carolina_PSC--NG--June_2019--[2019-6-G]Application of Dominion Energy South Carolina, Incorporated to Have the Terms of the Natural Gas Rate Stabilization Act Apply to the Company's Rates and Charges for Gas Distribution Services10.25%

The rate of return on rate base computed by ORS after the adjustments for the proposed increaseis 8.04%. The return on common equity is 10.25%.

Sep 3 2019Chesapeake Utilities Corp.Chesapeake Utilities Corp.Natural GasConnecticutOpen19-0573Chesapeake_Utilities_Corporation--Delaware_PSC--NG--Sep_2019--[19-0573]Chesapeake Utilities Corporation – Delaware Division Gas Sales Service RatesN/A

N/A

Aug 30 2019Midstates Natural Gas Corp.Liberty UtilitiesNatural GasMissouriClosedGT-2020-0055Liberty_Utilities--Missouri_PSC--NG--Sep_2019--[GT-2020-0055]Revised Weather Normalization Adjustment Rider Tariff RevisionN/A

N/A

Aug 30 2019Questar Gas Co.Dominion Energy Inc.Natural GasUtahOpen19-057-18Dominion_Energy--Utah_PSC--NG--Aug_2019--[19-057-18]Pass-Through Application of Dominion Energy Utah for Adjustment in RatesN/A

There will be no change in the Company’s rate of return. Net profits are also unaffected except for the return on the changed amount of working storage gas which was approved by the Commission in Docket No. 18-057-T01

Jun 28 2019Atmos Energy Corp.Atmos Energy Corp.Natural GasKansasOpen19-ATMG-525-RTSAtmos_Energy--Kansas_CC--Elec--June_2019--[19-ATMG-525-RTS]Application of Atmos Energy Corporation for Adjustment of its Natural Gas Rates in the State of Kansas10.25%

WACC is calculated using Atmos Energy’s actual capital structure at March 31, 2019, which consisted of 39.88% long-term debt at an embedded long-term debt cost rate of 4.57% and 60.12% common equity at my recommended return on common equity (“ROE”) of 10.25%

May 31 2019Chesapeake Utilities Corp.Chesapeake Utilities Corp.Natural GasConnecticutOpen19-0357Chesapeake_Utilities_Corp--Delaware_PSC--NG--May_2019--[19-0357]Application of Chesapeake Utilities Corporation for approval to implement a distribution system improvement chargeN/A

N/A

May 31 2019SEMCO Energy Gas Co.SEMCO EnergyNatural GasMichiganOpenU-20479SEMCO_Energy_Gas_Company--Michigan_PSC--NG--May_2019--[U-20479]SEMCO Energy Gas Company's Rate Case - Application10.50%

SEMCO Gas proposes that retail natural gas rates be established to reflect an overall rate of return on total rate base of 7.04% and a rate of return on common equity of 10.50%.

May 22 2019Columbia Gas of Maryland Inc.NiSource Inc.Natural GasMarylandOpen9609Columbia_Gas_of_Maryland_Inc--Maryland_PSC--NG--May_2019--[9609]Columbia Gas of Maryland, Inc. - Application for Authority to Increase Rates and Charges10.95%

Columbia is requesting approval of an overall rate of return of 7.927 percent and a return on equity of 10.95 percent,

OPEN (new)
May 20 2019Rochester Gas and Electric CorporationIberdrola SANatural GasNew YorkOpen19-G-0381Rochester_Gas_and_Electric_Corporation--New_York_PSC--NG--May_2019--[19-G-0381]Revenue Requirements Panel Testimony-Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation-19-G-03819.50%

The Companies are requesting Delivery revenues to be based on a 9.50% return on equity

OPEN (new)
May 20 2019New York State Electric & Gas CorporationIberdrola SANatural GasNew YorkOpen19-G-0379New_York_State_Electric_&_Gas_Corporation--New_York_PSC--NG--May_2019--[19-G-0379]Revenue Requirements Panel Testimony -New York State Electric & Gas Corporation-19-G-03799.50%

The Companies are requesting Delivery revenues to be based on a 9.50% return on equity (“ROE”)

OPEN (new)
Apr 30 2019Brooklyn Union Gas Co.National GridNatural GasNew YorkOpen19-G-0309Brooklyn_Union_Gas--New_York_PSC--NG--April_2019--[19-G-0309]Cover Letter with Attachments-The Brooklyn Union Gas Company9.65%

The Companies are requesting 10 an ROE of 9.65 percent

OPEN (Conference)
Apr 30 2019KeySpan Gas East Corp.National GridNatural GasNew YorkOpen19-G-0310KeySpan--New_York_PSC--NG--April_2019--[19-G-0310]Cover Letter9.65%

The Companies are requesting 10 an ROE of 9.65 percent

OPEN (Conference)
Apr 23 2019Northern Utilities Inc.Unitil Corp.Natural GasMaineOpen2019-00092Northern_Utilities--Maine_PUC--NG--April_2019--[2019-00092]Notice of Intent to File a General Rate Case10.50%

The Company expects to request (…) an approximatereturn on equity component of 10.5percent.

OPEN (Notice of Intent stage)
Apr 22 2019Washington Gas Light Co.AltaGas Ltd.Natural GasMarylandOpen9605Washington_Gas_Light--Maryland_PSC--NG--April_2019--[9605]Application Of Washington Gas Light Company For Authority To Increase Its Existing Rates And Charges10.40%

The Company respectfully requests an opportunity to earn (…) a return on common equity of 10.40%

OPEN (Testimony)
Apr 1 2019Piedmont Natural Gas Company, Inc.Duke Energy Corp.Natural GasNorth CarolinaOpenG-9 SUB 743Piedmont--North_Carolina_UC--NG--April_2019--[G-9 SUB 743]Application for a General Rate Increase10.20%

In August 2016, a settlement agreement was filed with the ORS stipulating an $8.3 million annualincrease in margin based on a return on equity of 10.2%, effective November 1, 2016. We are waiting on a ruling from the PSCSC at this time

OPEN (Statements & Petitions)
Mar 29 2019Cascade Natural Gas Corp.MDU Resources Group, Inc.Natural GasWashingtonPendingUG-190210Cascade_Natural_Gas--Washington_UTC--NG--March_2019--[UG-190210]Revises Tariff WN U-3, reflecting general rate case on behalf of Cascade Natural Gas Corp.10.30%

a range from 10.00to 10.75percent is 3reasonable. This recommendation reflects the range of results for the proxy group 4companies, the relative risk of Cascade’s natural gas operations in Washingtonas 5compared to theproxy group, and current capital market conditions. Within that 6range,a return of 10.30percent is reasonable

Mar 1 2019Interstate Power & Light Co.Alliant Energy Corp.Natural GasIowaOpenRPU-2019-0002Interstate_Power_Light--Iowa_UB--NG--March_2019--[RPU-2019-0002]Application for Increase in Natural Gas Rates (Part 3 of 4)10.00%

the proposed ROE of 10.0percent

Feb 28 2019Valley Energy Inc.Valley Energy Inc.Natural GasPennsylvaniaOpenR-2019-3008209Valley_Energy--Pennsylvania_PUC--NG--Feb_2019--[R-2019-3008209]Supplement No. 49 to Tariff Electric - Pa. P.U.C. No. 2 eff 8/30/19-Valley Energy, IncN/A

N/A

Jan 28 2019Peoples Natural Gas Co. LLCPNG Companies LLCNatural GasPennsylvaniaOpenR-2018-3006818Peoples_Natural_Gas--Pennsylvania_PUC--NG--Jan_2019--[R-2018-3006818]Rate Increase Filing - Peoples Natural Gas Company11.25%

Absent rate relief, the Company would earn a return on equity substantially lower than the Company’s proposed return on equity (“ROE”) of 11.25% in this proceeding

Peoples Natural shall use the equity return rate for gas utilities contained in the Commission’s most recent Quarterly Report on the Earnings of Jurisdictional Utilities and shall update the equityreturn rate each quarter consistent with any changes to the equity return rate for gas utilities contained in the most recent Quarterly Earnings ReportOpinion and Order
Jan 28 2019UGI Utilities Inc.UGI Corp.Natural GasPennsylvaniaOpenR-2018-3006814UGI_Utilities--Pennsylvania_PUC--NG--Jan_2019--[R-2018-3006814]Rate Increase Filing - Tariff Gas PA PUC No 7 & 7S - Eff 3/29/19 - UGI Gas11.25%

UGI Gas intends to demonstrate that its request for an overall annual distributionrevenue increase of approximately $71.1 million, based on a fully projected future test yearending September 30, 2020, and proposed allowed rate of return on equity of 11.25 percent isjust and reasonable and should be approved by the Commission.

UGI Gas shall use the equity return rate for gas utilities contained in the Commission’s most recent Quarterly Report on the Earnings of Jurisdictional Utilities and shall update the equity return rate each quarter.Rewrite Opinion and OrderOPEN (Pre-hearing stage)
Jan 7 2019Questar GasDominion EnergyNatural GasUtahOpen19-057-02Questar_Gas--Utah_PSC--NG--Jan_2019--[19-057-02]Notice of Intent to File a General Rate Case10.5%,

Proposed ROE 10.5%, 55% Equity capital structure

N/AWhole docket only has a single document with no information on it
Oct 1 2019Virginia Electric & Power Co.Dominion Energy Inc.Capital Cost/RiderVirginiaOpenPUR-2019-00160Virginia_Electric_and_Power--Virginia_SCC--Oct_2019--[ PUR-2019-00160]Application for revision of rate adjustment clause11.75%

The company has utilized an enhanced rate of return on common equity (“ROE”) of 11.75% for purposes of calculating the revenue requirement over the Rate Year in this 2019 Annual Update. This includes a proposed general ROE of 10.75% and a 100 basis points enhanced return, as provided for in Subsection A 6 for the combined-cycle generating station.

Sep 24 2019Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.Duke Energy Corp.RiderOhioOpen19-1751-GE-AAMDuke_Energy_Ohio--Ohio_PUCO--Sep_2019--[19-1751-GE-AAM]Application of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc., for Authority to Adjust its Power Forward Rider9.84%

As approved in the most recent electric distribution base rate case, the company will use a 9.84 percent rate of return on equity for the rider.

Sep 17 2019Union Electric Co.Ameren Corp.Fiber OpticMissouriOpenEM-2020-0075Union_Electric--Missouri_PSC--Sep_2019--[EM-2020-0075]Notice of Case FilingN/A

n/a

Aug 26 2019Delmarva Power & Light Co.Exelon Corp.Gas Cost Rate/Sales Service RateConnecticutOpen19-0556Delmarva_Power_and_Light--Delaware_PSC--NG--Aug_2019--[19-0556]Application of Delmarva Power & Light Company for Approval of Modifications to its Gas Cost RatesN/A

N/A

Aug 5 2019PacifiCorpBerkshire Hathaway EnergyEnergy, GHG CostsCaliforniaOpenA1908002PacifiCorp--California_PUC--Aug_2019--[A1908002]Application filed by PacifiCorpN/A
Jul 31 2019Indiana Michigan Power Co.American Electric Power Co.FAC/Wind PurchaseIndianaDecided38702 - FAC 83Indiana_Michigan_Power--Indiana_IURC--July_2019--[38702 - FAC 83]Indiana Michigan Power Company - petitionN/A

N/A

Jul 19 2019DTE Electric Co.DTE Energy Co.Time-Based RatesMichiganOpenU-20602DTE_Electric--Michigan_PSC--Elec--July_2019--[U-20602]Application for approval of Advanced Customer Pricing PilotN/A

N/A

Jul 9 2019Minnesota PowerAllete Inc.Transmission RiderMinnesotaOpenM-19-440Minnesota_Power--Minnesota_PUC--July_2019--[M-19-440]Petition for Transmission Cost Recovery RiderN/A

N/A

Jul 1 2019Ohio Gas Co.NWO Resources Inc.Alternative RegulationOhioOpen19-1354-GA-ALT, 19-1355-GA-ATAOhio-Gas-Company--Ohio_PSC--NG--July_2019--[19-1354-GA-ALT, 19-1355-GA-ATA]Notice of Intent of Ohio Gas Company to File an Application for Approval of an Alternative Rate PlanN/A

N/A

Jul 1 2019Avista Corp.Avista Corp.Fixed Cost AdjustmentIdahoOpenAVU-E-19-07Avista_Corp--Idaho_PUC--July_2019--[AVU-E-19-07]ApplicationN/A

N/A

Jun 28 2019KCP&L Greater Missouri Operations Co.Evergy Inc.Fuel and Purchased Power Cost Recovery MechanismMissouriOpenER-2019-0413KCP&L_Greater_Missouri_Operations_Company--Missouri_PSC--Elec--June_2019--[ER-2019-0413]Order Directing FilingN/A

N/A

May 24 2019Baltimore Gas and Electric Co.Exelon Corp.Electric, Natural GasMarylandOpen9610Baltimore_Gas_and_Electric_Company--Maryland_PSC--Elec_NG--May_2019--[9610]Baltimore Gas and Electric Company - its Application for the Adjustments to Electric and Gas Base Rates10.30%

BGE’s requested increasesto the electric and gas revenue requirements are based on a partially-projected test year for the 12 months ending July 31, 2019 (adjusted for certain known and measurable changes), a 10.30 percent return on equity (“ROE”)

OPEN (new)
Apr 30 2019Consumers Energy CompanyCMS EnergyInvestment Recovery MechanismMichiganOpenU-20522Consumers_Energy_Company--Michigan_PSC--April_2019--[U-20522]Consumers Energy Company's ApplicationN/A

N/A

Apr 23 2019San Diego Gas & Electric Co.SempraElectric, Natural GasCaliforniaOpenA1904017San_Diego_Gas_&_Electric--California_PUC--Elec--NG--April_2019--[A1904017]Application filed by San Diego Gas & Electric Co.12.38%

Lowers its requested Return on Equity (ROE) from 14.4 percent to 12.38 percent.

Apr 23 2019Pacific Gas and Electric Co.PG&E Corp.Cost of CapitalCaliforniaOpenA1904015Pacific_Gas_Electric--California_PUC--Elec--April_2019--[A1904015]Application_File16.00%

The proposed premium for asymetric risk in the requested ROE of 16 percent reflects the risks inherent in investing in PG&E and is the estimated minimum necessary to attract the capital to fund critical safety and reliability investments and operations.

OPEN (Protest)
Mar 29 2019Appalachian Power Co. and Wheeling Power Co.American Electric Power Co.Economic DevelopmentWest VirginiaOpen19-0387-E-PCAppalachian_Power_and_Wheeling_Power--West_Virginia_PSC--March_2019--[19-0387-E-PC]Petition for consent and approval of an Economic Development ProgramN/A

N/A

Mar 28 2019Wisconsin Public Service Corp.WEC Energy GroupElectric, Natural GasWisconsin6690-UR-126Wisconsin_Public_Service_Corp--Wisconsin_PSC--Elec_NG--March_2019--[6690-UR-126]Application Letter10.35%

I believe that a ROE of 10.35 percent for Wisconsin Public Service isreasonable and appropriate.

OPEN (Requests & Responses)
Mar 8 2019Idaho PowerIDACORP Inc.Coal Plant RetirementIdahoOpenIPC-E-19-08Idaho_Power--Idaho_PUC--March_2019--[IPC-E-19-08]ApplicationN/A

N/A

Mar 7 2019Unitil Energy Systems Inc.Unitil Corp.Electric - Default Service SolicitationNew HampshireOpenDE 19-049Unitil_Energy_Systems--New_Hampshire_PUC--Elec--March_2019--[DE 19-049]PetitionN/A

N/A

Mar 1 2019Dayton Power and Light Co.AES Corp.Tax RiderOhioOpen19-0572-EL-UNCDayton_Power_Light--Ohio_PUC--Tax_Rider--March_2019--[19-0572-EL-UNC]Application of The Dayton Power and Light Companys Implementation of Certain Matters Relating to the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017N/A

N/A

N/ANo mention of ROE and its variations anywhere in the docket
Jan 31 2019Consolidated EdisonConsolidated EdisonElectric and GasNew YorkOpen19-E-0065Con_Edison--New_York_PSC--Elec-NG--Jan_2019--[19-E-0065]2019 CECONY Filing Letter and Attachments-Consolidated Edison Company of New York9.75%

proposed return on equity (“ROE”)of 9.75percent

OPEN (Rebuttal testimony)
Jan 23 2019Dayton Power and Light Co.AES Corp.Distribution Modernization RiderOhioOpen19-0162-EL-RDRDayton_Power_Light--Ohio_PUC--Jan_2019--[19-0162-EL-RDR]Application of The Dayton Power and Light Company for Extension of Distribution Modernization RiderN/A

N/A

N/ANo mention of ROE and its variations anywhere in the docket, only stuff about Cost Riders
Jan 14 2019Ohio Power Co.American Electric Power Co.TransmissionOhioOpen19-0133-EL-RDROhio_Power--Ohio_PUC--Trans--Jan_2019--[19-0133-EL-RDR]Application of Ohio Power Company to Update Its Basic Transmission Cost RiderN/A

N/A

N/ANo mention of ROE and its variations anywhere in the docket
Jan 8 2019Duke Energy OhioDuke Energy CorporationAlternative EnergyOhioOpen19-0051-EL-RDRDuke_Energy_Ohio--Ohio_PUC--Elec--Jan_2019--[19-0051-EL-RDR]In the Matter of the Review of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc's Alternative Energy Recovery Rider.N/A

N/A

N/ANo mention of ROE and its variations anywhere in the docket
Jan 7 2019Vectren Energy Delivery of OhioUtility Holding LLCTax RiderOhioOpen19-0029-GA-ATAVectren_Energy_Ohio--Ohio_PUC--Tax--Jan_2019--[19-0029-GA-ATA]In the matter of the application of Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio, Inc. for Approval of a Tax Savings Credit RiderN/A

N/A

N/ANo mention of ROE and its variations anywhere in the docket
2018
Dec 31 2018East Ohio Gas Co.Dominion Energy Inc.Natural GasOhioOpen18-1909-GA-ATAEast_Ohio_Gas--Ohio_PUC--NG--Dec_2018--[18-1909-GA-ATA]In the Matter of the Application for Approval of Tariff RevisionsN/A

N/A

N/AN/AN/ANo mention of ROE and its variations anywhere in the docket
Dec 31 2018East Ohio Gas Co.Dominion Energy Inc.Tax Cut RiderOhioOpen18-1908-GA-UNCEast_Ohio_Gas--Ohio_PUCO--Dec_2018--[18-1908-GA-UNC]In the Matter of the Application Regarding Implementation of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017N/A

N/A

N/AN/AN/AN/A
Dec 31 2018NW Natural (Northwest Natural Gas Co.)NW Natural (Northwest Natural Gas Co.)Natural GasWashingtonDecidedUG-181053NW_Natural--Washington_UTC--NG--Dec_2018--[UG-181053]Revises Tariff WN U-6, on behalf of Northwest Natural Gas Company, from Zachary Kravitz.10.3% 9.40%

The Company’s request is based on a proposed rate of return of 7.63 percent, return on equity of 10.3 percent,

9.40%Order 06 Final Order Rejecting Tariff Sheets; Approving and Adopting Joint Settlement Agreement43759N/A
Dec 28 2018Northeast Ohio Natural Gas Corp.Hearthstone Utilities Inc.Natural GasOhioDecided18-1720-GA-AIRNortheast_Ohio_Natural_Gas_Corp--Ohio_PUCO--NG--Nov_2018--[18-1720-GA-AIR]Application to Increase Rates and Charges8.6% 8.12%

NEO submits that a return of 8.66% is fair and reasonable.

8.12%Opinion & Order that the Commission adopts the stipulation resolving all issues related to Northeast Ohio Natural Gas Corp.s combined applications for an increase in rates and for an alternative rate plan43734N/A
Dec 26 2018Duke Energy Kentucky Inc.Duke Energy Corp.Gas AdjustmentKentuckyClosed2018-00427Duke_Energy_Kentucky--Kentucky_PSC--NG--Dec_2018--[2018-00427]Notice of Intent to File Application for Purchased Gas AdjustmentN/A

N/A

N/AN/AN/ANo mention of ROE and its variations anywhere in the docket
Dec 19 2018Commonwealth Edison CompanyExelon Corp.Time of UseIllinoisClosed18-1824Commonwealth_Edison--Illinois_CC--Elec--Dec_2018--[18-1824]Direct Testimony of Commonwealth Edison CompanyN/A

N/A

N/AN/AN/AN/A
Dec 17 2018Pacific Gas and Electric Co.PG&E Corp.ElectricCaliforniaActiveA1812009Pacific_Gas_Elec--California_PUC--Elec--Dec_2018--[A1812009]Application filed by PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY on 12/13/2018 Conf# 12882210.25%

Return on Equity 10.25% (displayed in a table showing revenues at proposed rates)

N/AN/AOPEN (Rulling)
Dec 17 2018Pacific Gas and Electric Co.PG&E Corp.Natural GasCaliforniaOpenA1812009Pacific_Gas_Elec--California_PUC--NG--Dec_2018--[A1812009]Application filed by PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY on 12/13/2018 Conf# 12882210.25%

Return on Equity 10.25% (displayed in a table showing revenues at proposed rates)

N/AN/AOPEN (Rulling)
Dec 14 2018Virginia Electric and Power Co.Dominion Energy Inc.EnvironmentalVirginiaOpenPUR-2018-00195Virginia_Electric_&_Power--Virginia_SCC--Dec_2018--[PUR-2018-00195]Petition for approval of a rate adjustment clause designated Rider EN/A

N/A

N/AN/AN/ATo calculate the revenue requirement in this case, Dominion utilized a rate of return on common equity of 9.2 percent, which was approved by the commission case no: PUR-2017-00038
Dec 14 2018Hawai'i Electric Light Company, Inc.Hawaiian Electric IndustriesElectricHawaiiOpen2018-0368Hawaii_Electric--Hawaii_PUC--Elec--Dec_2018--[2018-0368]Hawai'i Electric Light Company, Inc., 2019 Test Year, Application; Docket No. 2018-036810.50%

In this rate case, Hawai Electric Light requests (…) a rate of return on common equity (“ROE”) of 10.50%

N/AN/AN/AOPEN (Letters stage)
Dec 11 2018Peoples Gas of KYSteelRiver Infrastructure PartnersGas AdjustmentKentuckyInactive2018-00412People_Gas_Kentucky--Kentucky_PSC--NG--Dec_2018--[2018-00412]Peoples Gas of KY, LLC Notice of Intent to File Application for Purchased Gas AdjustmentN/A

N/A

N/AN/AN/AOPEN but No mention of ROE and its variations anywhere in the docket
Dec 10 2018Southwestern Electric Power Co.American Electric Power Co.ElectricArkansasClosed15-002-USouthwestern_Electric--Arkansas_PSC--Elec--Dec_2018--[15-002-U]Notice Of Intent To File An Application For A General Change In RatesN/A

N/A

N/AN/AN/AOPEN but No mention of ROE and its variations anywhere in the docket
Dec 4 2018Northern Illinois Gas CompanyNicor Gas CompanyNatural GasIllinoisClosed18-1775Northern_Illinois_Gas--Illinois_CC--NG--Dec_2018--[18-1775]Direct Testimony on behalf of Northern Illinois Gas Company10.6% 9.73%

The Company proposes a Return on Equity (“ROE”) of 10.60% 195 per annum, inclusive of flotation costs, and an overall Rate of Return (“ROR”) on 196 rate base of 7.88% per annum.

9.73%Final Order12/4/2018N/A
Dec 3 2018Union Electric Co.Ameren Corp.Natural GasMissouriOpenGR-2019-0077Union_Electric--Missouri_PSC--NG--Dec_2018--[GR-2019-0077]Minimum Filing Requirement Letter and MFR Schedules10.30%

the Company considers 10.30% to be a fair and equitable return on equity (“ROE”)

N/AN/AN/AOPEN (still in Testimony stage)
Nov 15 2018National GridNational GridElectricMassachusettsOpen18-150National_Grid--Massachusetts_DPU--Elec--Nov_2018--[18-150]Transmittal Documents: Letter of Explanation; Letter of Tariff Advice; Petition for Approval10.5% 9.60%

National Grid has asked for a return on equity of 10.5%

9.60%ORDER. By Chair Nelson, Commissioners Hayden and Fraser30 Sep, 2019N/A
Oct 8 2018Duke Energy ProgressDuke Energy Corp.ElectricRhode IslandOpen2018-318-EDuke_Energy_Progress--S_Carolina_PSC--Elec--Oct_2018--[2018-318-E]DEP's Letter and Notice of Intent to File Application10.5% 9.50%

Company has proposing setting rates at a 10.50 percent ROE.

9.50%Order Number 2019-34121 May, 2019N/A
Oct 3 2018Virginia Electric & Power Co.Dominion Energy Inc.ElectricVirginiaOpenPUR-2018-00166Virginia_Electric_Power--Virginia_SCC--Elec--March_2018--[PUR-2018-00166]Application for revision of rate adjustment clauseN/A10.20%

N/A

N/AN/AN/AOPEN but it seems to be about Rider BW instead of ROE? - Dominion proposes an enhanced rate of return on common equity ("ROE") of 10.2% which it states is supported by the Commission's Final Order in Case No. PUR-2017-00038
Oct 3 2018Virginia Electric & Power Co.Dominion Energy Inc.ElectricVirginiaOpenPUR-2018-00167Virginia_Electric_Power--Virginia_SCC--Elec--March_2018--[PUR-2018-00167]Virginia Electric and Power Company - Public Version - Application for revision of a rate adjustmentN/A9.20%Virginia Electric & Power Co - Public Version - Application for revision of a rate adjustment clause: Rider US-2, Scott, Whitehouse & Woodland Solar Power Stations, for Rate Year Commencing 9/1/19. (part 3 of 7 - Testimony of J. Robertson)

N/A

N/AN/AN/AOPEN but it seems to be about Rider US-2 instead of ROE? - Specifically, the Company has requested in this 2018 Annual Update that the general ROE of 9.2% as ordered in the Commission's Final Order in Case No. PUR-2017:00038
Oct 1 2018Oklahoma Gas and Electric Co.OGE Energy Corp.ElectricArkansasOpen18-046-FROklahoma_Gas_Electric--Arkansas_PSC--Elec--Oct_2018--[18-046-FR]Oklahoma Gas and Electric Company submits Motion for Interim Protective Order. Establishes DocketN/A

N/A

N/AN/AN/ADoesn't seem to be about ROE/rates/etc - Formula Rate Plan Filings Of Oklahoma Gas And Electric Company
Oct 1 2018Consumers Energy Co.CMS EnergyNatural GasMichiganOpenU-20322Consumers_Energy--Michigan_PSC--NG--Oct_2018--[U-20322]Consumers Energy Company's Filing Announcement10.75% 9.9 %

An equity ratio of 52.50% and an ROE of 10.75% as 7recommended by the Company in this case results in a FFO to debt ratio that is sufficient 8in striking this balance

9.90%Correction: MPSC approves rate increase for Consumers Energy gas customers; utility to increase infrastructure upgrades, enhance technologies9/26/2019N/A
Sep 28 2018Atmos Energy Corp.Atmos Energy Corp.Natural GasKentuckyInactive2018-00281Atmos_Energy--Kentucky_PSC--NG--Sept_2018--[2018-00281]Atmos Energy Corporation Notice of Intent to File General Adjustment in Rates10.4% 9.65%10.40%Eric Wilen Atmos Energy Corporation - Application for an Adjustment of Rates and Tariff Modifications - 2018-00281_Atmos_Kentucky_Rate_Case_Filing_(Volumes_1__2)_2018-09-28

Based on a proposed ROE of 10.40 percent Atmos determined that it required a revenue increase

9.65%20190507_PSC_ORDER5/7/2019N/A
Sep 28 2018MDU Resources Group Inc.MDU Resources Group Inc.ElectricMontanaOpenD2018.9.60MDU_Resources--Montana_PSC--Elec--Sept_2018--[D2018.9.60]Application, Appendices, and Direct Testimonies10.30%

Montana-Dakota is requesting an overall return of 7.542 percent, 2inclusive of a return on equity (ROE) of 10.3 percent

N/AN/AN/AOPEN
Sep 28 2018NorthWestern Corp.NorthWestern Corp.ElectricMontanaOpenD2018.2.12NorthWestern_Corp--Montana_PSC--Elec--Sept_2018--[D2018.2.12]Notice Of Opportunity To Comment10.65%

NWE requested approval of an increase in annual base electric rate revenue in the amount of $34,861,573, a return on equity of 10.65%,

N/AStipulation and Settlement Agreement of NorthWestern Energy and The Northwest Energy Coalition5/20/2019N/A
Sep 28 2018Kentucky Utilities Co.PPL Corp.ElectricKentuckyOpen2018-00294Kentucky_Utilities--Kentucky_PSC--Elec--Sept_2018--[2018-00294]Kentucky Utilities Company Notice of Intent to File Application for an Adjustment of Its Electric Rates Using Electronic Filing Procedures - 2018082710.42% 9.73%10.42%Derek A Rahn Kentucky Utilities Company - Kentucky Utilities Companys Statutory Notice, Customer Notice of Rate Adjustment, Application, Filing Requirements, Direct Testimony, and Petition for Confidential Protection for of an adjustment of its El...

KU’s proposal has requested a 10.42% return on equity

9.73%KENTUCKY UTILITIES COMPANY - GENERAL RATES4/30/2019N/A
Sep 28 2018Louisville Gas & Electric Co.PPL Corp.ElectricKentuckyOpen2018-00295Louisville_Gas_Electric--Kentucky_PSC--Elec--Sept_2018--[2018-00295]Derek A Rahn - Louisville Gas and Electric Companys Statutory Notice, Customer Notice of Rate Adjustment, Application, Filing Requirements10.42% 9.73%10.42%Derek A Rahn Louisville Gas and Electric Company - Louisville Gas and Electric Companys Statutory Notice, Customer Notice of Rate Adjustment, Application, Filing Requirements, Direct Testimony, and Petition for Confidential Protection for of an ad...

LG&E and KU announced its plans to file requests with the KPSC for a $172 million (5.5%) rate increase premised upon an 10.42% return on equity.

9.73%LOUISVILLE GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY - GENERAL RATES4/30/2019N/A
Sep 28 2018Louisville Gas & Electric Co.PPL Corp.Natural GasKentuckyOpen2018-00295Louisville_Gas_Electric_Kentucky_PSC--NG--Sept_2018--[2018-00295]Derek A Rahn - Louisville Gas and Electric Companys Statutory Notice, Customer Notice of Rate Adjustment, Application, Filing Requirements10.42% 9.73%10.42%Derek A Rahn Louisville Gas and Electric Company - Louisville Gas and Electric Companys Statutory Notice, Customer Notice of Rate Adjustment, Application, Filing Requirements, Direct Testimony, and Petition for Confidential Protection for of an ad...

LG&E and KU announced its plans to file requests with the KPSC for a $172 million (5.5%) rate increase premised upon an 10.42% return on equity.

9.73%LOUISVILLE GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY - GENERAL RATES4/30/2019N/A
Sep 26 2018Public Service Co. of OKAmerican Electric Power Co.ElectricOklahomaInactivePUD-201800097Public_Service_OK-Oklahoma_CC-E-Sept_2018-[PUD-201800097]Document Number 3011784410.3% 9.40%

The equity rate is the 10.3% return on equity requested by PSO in this filing

9.40%Document Number 302150403/14/2019N/A
Aug 31 2018Duke Energy Kentucky Inc.Duke Energy Corp.Natural GasKentuckyInactiveC-2018-00261Duke_Energy_Kentucky--Kentucky_PSC--NG--Aug_2018--[2018-00261]Duke Energy Kentucky, Inc. Notice of Intent to File Application for 1) Authority to Adjust Natural Gas Rates; 2) Approval of a Decoupling Mechanism; 3) Approval of New Tariffs; 4) All Other Required Approvals, Waivers, and Relief10.4% 9.70%9.90%Deborah Gates - Upload #4 - Application for An Adjustment of the Natural Gas Rates - volume_15.3

Duke Energy Ohio has requested an estimated annual increase of approximately $15 million and a return on equity of 10.4 percent.

9.70%DUKE ENERGY KENTUCKY, INC. - OTHER3/27/2019N/A
Aug 31 2018Suburban Natural Gas Co.Suburban Natural Gas Co.Natural GasOhioOpen18-1205-GA-AIRSuburban_Natural_Gas--Ohio_PUC--NG--July_2018--[18-1207-GA-AAM]Application Of Suburban Natural Gas Company For An Increase In Rates And Charges10.25% 10.25%

The Stipulation provides for a just and reasonable rate of return of 7.26 percent and a return on common equity of 10.25 percent.

10.25%Opinion & Order that the Commission adopts the joint stipulation and recommendation resolving all issues related to Suburban Natural Gas Companys application to increase its natural gas distribution rates. electronically filed by Docketing Staff8/31/2018N/A
Aug 28 2018Columbia Gas of Virginia IncNiSource Inc.Natural GasVirginiaOpenPUR-2018-00131Columbia_Gas_Virginia--Virginia_SCC--NG--August_2018--[PUR-2018-00131]Columbia Gas of Virginia, Inc. - Application for authority to increase rates & charges & to revise the terms & conditions applicable to gas service. - Volume 4 - (Part 24 of 30 - Schedules 37 through 39)10.95% 9.70%10.95%Columbia Gas of Virginia, Inc. - Application for authority to increase rates & charges & to revise the terms & conditions applicable to gas service. - Volume 1 - (Part 1 of 30 - Application)

requested return on equity of 10.95%

9.70%Columbia Gas of Virginia, Inc. - Final Order - 6/12/19.6/22/2019N/A
Aug 24 2018Potomac Edison Co.FirstEnergy Corp.ElectricMarylandOpen9490Potomac_Edison--Maryland_PSC--Elec--Aug_2018--[9490]The Potomac Edison Company filed, on August 24, 2018, an Application for Adjustments to its Retail Rates for the Distribution of Electric Energy10.8% 9.65%10.10%The Potomac Edison Company filed, on August 24, 2018, an Application for Adjustments to its Retail Rates for the Distribution of Electric Energy along with direct testimonies and exhibits. Case No. 9490. - ThePotomacEdisonCompanyMDApplicationforAd...

The increase is based on a test year for the 12-month period from July 1, 2017 through June 30, 2018, and an overall rate of return on investment of 7.75%, and an overall ROE of 10.8%.

9.65%- Order No. 89072 Case No. 9490. (ML 224417)3/22/2019N/A
Aug 21 2018Atlantic City Electric Co.Exelon Corp.ElectricNew JerseyInactiveER18080925Atlantic_City_Electric--NJ_BPU--Elec--Aug_2018--[ER18080925]In The Matter of the Petition of Atlantic City Electric Company for Approval of Amendments to its Tariff to Provide for an Increase in Rates and Charges for Electric Service10.1% 9.60%10.10%Board Orders - ER18080925 - 9-17-18-II A

The Company is also requesting a return on equity of 10.10%

9.60%Board Orders - ER18080925 - 3-13-19-2D3/13/2019N/A
Aug 15 2018Columbia Gas of Virginia IncNiSource Inc.Natural GasVirginiaClosedPUR-2018-00132Columbia_Gas_Virginia--Virginia_SCC--NG--August_2018--[PUR-2018-00132]Application for approval to implement a 2019 SAVE Plan Infrastructure Reliability & Replacement AdjustmentN/A

N/A

N/AN/AN/ALooked on and off the platform but couldn't find any mentions of ROE
Aug 10 2018Public Service Company of OklahomaAmerican Electric Power Co.ElectricOklahomaClosedPUD-201800097AEP--Oklahoma_CC--Elec--Aug_2018--[PUD-201800097]Application Of Public Service Company Of Oklahoma, An Oklahoma Corporation, For An Adjustment In Its Rates And Charges And The Electric Service Rules, Regulations And Conditions Of Service For Electric Service In The State Of Oklahoma9.4% 9.40%

The Stipulating Parties request that the Commission find a base rate revenue deficiency of $46 million based upon a return on equity of 9.40 percent

9.40%Document Number 302150403/14/2019N/A
Aug 2 2018San Diego Gas & Electric Co.Sempra EnergyNatural GasCaliforniaOpenA1807024SDGE_California_PUC--NG--Aug_2018--[A1807024]Application filed by Southern California Gas Company and and San Diego Gas & Electric CompanyN/A

N/A

N/AN/AN/ALooked on and off the platform but couldn't find any mentions of ROE
Aug 1 2018Southern Indiana Gas & Elec Co.Vectren Corp.ElectricIndianaOpen44910-TDSIC-3Southern_Indiana_Gas_Elec--Indiana_URC--Elec--Aug_2018--[44910-TDSIC-3]Southern Indiana Gas and Electric Company - Electric - PETITION10.40%

The return on equity (“ROE”) included in the weighted average cost of capital 9(“WACC”) will be 10.4%.

N/AN/AOne of the testimonies mention that "cost of equity has been set at 10.4% as approved in Vectren South’s Rate Case Orderand agreed to in the 44910 Settlement."
Jul 31 2018Duke Energy Florida LLCDuke Energy Corp.ElectricFloridaClosed20180149Duke_Energy_Florida--Florida_PSC--Elec--July_2018--[20180149]Duke Energy Florida, LLC [Duke Energy] (Triplett) - Petition for a limited proceeding to approve first solar base rate adjustment;N/A

N/A

N/AN/AN/ANo specific mention about request for ROE. Application says: These amountshave been calculated in accordance 2017 Settlement,which requires that the revenue requirements be “calculated using a 10.5% ROE
Jul 24 2018Virginia Electric & Power Co.Dominion Energy Inc.ElectricVirginiaOpenPUR-2018-00101Virginia_Electric_Power--Virginia_SCC--Elec--March_2018--[PUR-2018-00101]Petition for approval and certification of the proposed US-3 Solar Projects and for approval of a rate adjustment clause, designated Rider US-3. (part 1 of 12 - Petition)N/A9.20%Virginia Electric & Power Co - Public Version - Petition for approval & certification of proposed US-3 Solar Projects & for approval of a rate adjustment clause, designated Rider US-3. (part 6 of 12 - Direct Testimony of A. Moore)

N/A

N/AN/AN/ALooked on and off the platform but couldn't find any mentions of ROE
Jul 6 2018DTE Electric Co.DTE Energy Co.ElectricMichiganOpenU-20162DTE_Electric--Michigan_PSC--Elec--July_2018--[U-20162]U-20162-0001 DTE Electric Companys Filing Announcement10.5% 10.00%

The Company is requesting a Return on Equity of 10.5%

10.00%U-20162-0604 Authorizes DTE Electric Company to increase its rates by $273,334,000, on a jurisdictional basis, which includes the expiration of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 Credit A, effective May 9, 20195/2/2019N/A
Jun 29 2018CT Natural Gas Corp.IberdrolaNatural GasConnecticutOpen18-05-16CT_Natural_Gas--Connecticut_PURA--NG--June_2018--[18-05-16]18-05-16 - Application File10.2% 9.30%10.20%Prefiled testimony: 06/29/2018 - Sponsor: TBD / Witness: Anthony Marone [18-05-16]

The SFR schedules reflect a 10.20 percent return on equity (“ROE”)

9.30%2018 Connecticut Natural Gas Final Rate Case Decision12/31/2018FOUND at avangridinc.gcs-web.com
Jun 29 2018Chesapeake Utilities Corp.Chesapeake Utilities Corp.Natural GasConnecticutClosed18-0934Chesapeake_Utilities--Delaware_PSC--NG--June_2018--[18-0934]Notice of Intent to File a General Rate Increase Application for Chesapeake Utilities CorporationN/A

N/A

N/AN/AN/ALooked on and off the platform but couldn't find any mentions of ROE
Jun 15 2018Atmos Energy Corp.Atmos Energy Corp.Natural GasTennesseeClosed1800067Atmos_Energy--Tennessee_RA--NG--June_2018--[1800067]PetitionN/A

N/A

N/AN/AN/ALooked on and off the platform but couldn't find any mentions of ROE
Jun 15 2018Yankee Gas Services Co.Eversource EnergyNatural GasConnecticutOpen18-05-10Yankee_Gas--Connecticut_PURA--NG--June_2018 [18-05-10]Application File10.25% 9.30%10.25%Prefiled testimony Sponsor: 06/15/2018 TBD / Witness: Ann E. Bulkley [18-05-10] Bulkley - ROE PFT (6-15-2018.final)x

The requested rate of return is based on a return on equity of 10.25%

9.30%Compliance Filings, 01/11/2019 [18-05-10] Order No.YGS dba Eversource Energy / Compliance 180510-1212181/11/2019N/A
Jun 8 2018Baltimore Gas and Electric Co.Exelon Corp.Natural GasMarylandInactive9484Baltimore_Gas--Maryland_PSC--NG--June_2018--[9484]Baltimore Gas and Electric Company - an Application for Adjustments to its Gas Base Rates and Other Tariff Revisions. Case No. 948410.5% 9.80%[no exact number found] - "Company Witness McKenzie proposes that the Commission authorize an 18 upward ROE adjustment of 20 basis points to help address the attrition problem."Baltimore Gas and Electric Company filed, on June 08, 2018, an Application for Adjustments to its Gas Base Rates and Other Tariff Revisions. Case No. 9484 - 5_HolmesDirectTestimonywATT_Final

BGE’s proposed return on equity (“ROE”) of 10.5%

9.80%- Order No. 88975 Case No. 9484. (ML 223478)1/4/2019N/A
Jun 7 2018Missouri Gas EnergySpire Inc.Natural GasMissouriClosedGO-2018-0310Missouri_Gas_Energy--Missouri_PSC--NG--June_2018--[GO-2018-0310]Spire Missouri, Inc.'s Request for Waiver or Notice of Intended Case FilingsN/A

N/A

N/AN/AN/ALooked on and off the platform but couldn't find any mentions of ROE
Jun 7 2018Spire Missouri Inc.Spire Inc.Natural GasMissouriClosedGO-2018-0309Missouri_Gas_Energy--Missouri_PSC--NG--June_2018--[GO-2018-0309]Spire Missouri, Inc.'s Request for Waiver of Rule 4 CSR 4.017(1) for ISRS Case Filings, or in the Alternative, Notice of Intended Case FilingsN/A

N/A

N/AN/AN/ALooked on and off the platform but couldn't find any mentions of ROE
Jun 1 2018Virginia Electric & Power Co.Dominion Energy Inc.ElectricVirginiaOpenPUR-2018-00083Virginia_Electric_Power--Virginia_SCC--Elec--March_2018--[PUR-2018-00083]Appli for revision of rate adjustment clause: Rider B, Biomass Conversion of Altavista, Hopewell & Southampton Power Stations for Rate Year Commencing 4/1/19. (part 6 of 7 - Schedule 46B)N/A

N/A

N/AVirginia Electric and Power Company - Final Order - 2/27/192/27/2019Mentions a Rider B but no direct language regarding authorized ROE?
Jun 1 2018Virginia Electric & Power Co.Dominion Energy Inc.ElectricVirginiaOpenPUR-2018-00084Virginia_Electric_Power--Virginia_SCC--Elec--March_2018--[PUR-2018-00084]Application for revision of rate adjustment clause: Rider GV, Greensville County Power Station for the Rate Year Commencing April 1, 2019. (Part 1 of 7 - Application)N/A

N/A

N/AVirginia Electric and Power Company - Final Order - 2/27/192/27/2019Mentions a Rider GV but no direct language regarding authorized ROE?
Jun 1 2018Virginia Electric & Power Co.Dominion Energy Inc.ElectricVirginiaOpenPUR-2018-00085Virginia_Electric_Power--Virginia_SCC--Elec--March_2018--[PUR-2018-00085]Application for revision of rate adjustment clause: Rider R, Bear Garden Generating Station for the Rate Year Commencing 4/1/19. (part 1 of 4 - Application)N/A

N/A

N/AVirginia Electric and Power Company - Final Order - 2/27/192/27/2019Mentions a Rider R but no direct language regarding authorized ROE?
Jun 1 2018Virginia Electric & Power Co.Dominion Energy Inc.ElectricVirginiaOpenPUR-2018-00086Virginia_Electric_Power--Virginia_SCC--Elec--March_2018--[PUR-2018-00086]Application for revision of rate adjustment clause: Rider S, Virginia City Hybrid Energy Center for Rate Year Commencing 4/1/19. (part 1 of 5 - Application)N/A

N/A

N/AVirginia Electric and Power Company - Final Order - 2/27/192/27/2019Mentions a Rider S but no direct language regarding authorized ROE?
Jun 1 2018Virginia Electric & Power Co.Dominion Energy Inc.ElectricVirginiaOpenPUR-2018-00087Virginia_Electric_Power--Virginia_SCC--Elec--March_2018--[PUR-2018-00087]Virginia Electric and Power Company - Application for revision of rate adjustment clause: Rider W, Warren County Power Station for the Rate Year Commencing April 1, 2019.N/A

N/A

N/AVirginia Electric and Power Company - Final Order - 2/27/19.2/27/2019Mentions a Rider W but no direct language regarding authorized ROE:Mention the ROEs used for the calculation (separate ROEs for cost recovery component and true-up factor approved by commission - for cost recovery factor utilized an enhanced ROE of 10.2% comprised of a general ROE of 9.2%, and a 100 basis points enhanced return. For Actual Cost True-Up Factor, the Company utilized an ROE of 10.6% for January 2017 through March 2017, which comprises the general ROE of 9.6% plus the 100 basis points enhanced return; an ROE of 10.4% for April 1, 2017, through November 28,2017, which comprises the general ROE of 9.4% plus the 100 basis point enhanced return; and an ROE of 10.2% for the period of November 29,2017, through December 31,2017, which comprises the general ROE of 9.2% plus the 100 basis point enhanced return.
May 31 2018CascadeMdu Resources Group IncNatural GasOregonAcceptedUG 347Cascade--Oregon_PUC--NG--May_2018--[UG 347]INITIAL UTILITY FILING - CASCADE NATURAL GAS REQUEST FOR A GENERAL RATE REVISION9.4% 9.40%

The Company believes 1 O that an ROE of 9.4 percent represents a fair return for both shareholders and customers

9.40%UG 347, ORDER, 3/14/20193/14/2019FOUND at apps.puc.state.or.us
May 30 2018Texas-New Mexico Power Co.PNM Resources Inc.ElectricTexasInactive48401Texas-New_Mexico_Power--Texas_PUC--Elec--May_2018--[48401]Texas-New Mexico Power Company - Application of Texas-New Mexico Power Company for Authority to Change Rates10.5% 9.65%

TNMP proposes here a 10.5% return on equity

9.65%PUC OPDM - FINAL ORDER12/20/2018N/A
May 29 2018Southwest Gas Corp.Southwest Gas Holdings Inc.Natural GasNevadaOpen18-05031Southwest_Gas_Corp--Nevada_PUC--NG--May_2018--[18-05031]Application & Prehearing10.3% 9.10-9.70%

The Company’s proposed 10 30% return for equity

9.10-9.70%Modified Order issued2/15/2019N/A
May 17 2018Berkshire Gas Co.IberdrolaNatural GasMassachusettsOpen18-40Berkshire_Gas--Massachusetts_DPU--NG--May_2018--[18-40]Initial Filing - Book I - Transmittal Documents.9.2% 9.70%

The filing parties seek an order from the FERC reducing the 11.14% base return on equity used incalculating formula rates for transmission service under the ISO-New England Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) to a just and reasonable level of 9.2%.

9.70%ORDER ON PROPOSED SETTLEMENT. By Chairman O'Connor, Commissioners Hayden and Fraser. DPU 18-40-B1/18/2019N/A
May 15 2018Entergy Texas Inc.Entergy Corp.ElectricTexasClosed48371Entergy_Texas--Texas_PUC--Elec--May_2018--[48371]Entergy Texas, Inc.`s Statement of Intent and Application for Authority to Change Rates10.65% 9.65%

ETI proposes an ROE of 10.65%, as recommended by Mr. Hevert.

9.65%PUC OPDM - ORDER12/20/2018N/A
May 14 2018Consumers Energy Co.CMS Energy Corp.ElectricMichiganOpenU-20134Consumers_Energy--Michigan_PSC--Elec--May_2018--[U-20134]Consumers Energy Company's Filing Announcement10.75% 10%

The Company is also seeking a return on equity (“ROE”) of 10.75%

10%U-20134-0386 Press Release Michigan Public Service Commission (MPSC)1/9/2019N/A
May 9 2018Appalachian Power Co.American Electric Power Co.ElectricWest VirginiaOpen18-0646-E-42TAppalachian_Power--West_Virginia_PSC--Elec--May_2018--[18-0646-E-42T]Appalachian Power Company and Wheeling Power Company9.75% 9.75%

The adjustments that produce the recommended increase agreed upon by the Stipulating Parties, which are shown on page 1 of Exhibit 1 and supported by the cost of service summary shown on page 2 of Exhibit 1, reflect the following: A return on equity for the Companies of 9.75%

9.75%Appalachian Power Company and Wheeling Power Company2/27/2019N/A
May 2 2018Interstate Power & Light Co.Alliant Energy Corp.Natural GasIowaOpenRPU-2018-0002InterstatePower&Light-IowaUB-NG-May2018-[RPU-2018-0002]Application for Approval of Non-Standard Notices9.8% 9.60%

IPL filed with the Iowa Utilities Board (Board) a general rate review proceeding requesting a $19,796,857 increase in its Iowa retail revenue requirements for its natural gas operations based on a return on equity of 9.8%

9.60%Order Approving Settlement and Requiring Reports12/12/2018N/A
Apr 25 2018Duke Energy Indiana LLCDuke Energy Corp.ElectricIndianaPending44720 - TDSIC 4Duke_Energy_Indiana--Indiana_URC--Elec--April_2018--[44720-TDSIC 4]Duke Energy Indiana, LLC - PETITION10% 10%

The ratemaking treatment approved by the Commissionwas presented in the direct and 7settlement testimony and exhibits of Mr. Brian P. Davey in Cause No. 44720 and8included: (1) the timely recovery via a newly established tracking mechanism (Rider 65)9of eighty percent (80%) of the retail jurisdictional share of the T&D Plan costs, subject to 10annual and cumulative caps on T&D Plan capital investment as set forthin the Settlement 11Agreement approved in the TDSIC Order,1including recovery of return oncapital12investments using the Company’s weighted cost of capital at each Cutoff Date,using a 10% cost of equity

10%Ind. regulators OK Duke Energy's revamped grid modernization plan6/30/2018FOUND at https://www.spglobal.com/
Apr 20 2018Otter Tail Power Co.Otter Tail Corp.ElectricSouth DakotaClosedEL18-021Otter_Tail--South_Dakota_PUC--Elec--April_2018--[EL18-021]Volume 1 - Letter of Transmittal, Application, Notice of Proposed Change of Rates and Charges, Attestation, Request for Confidential Treatment and Statements10% 8.75%

the Company included a 10.0% return on equity in its calculations, based on its last rate case settlement.

8.75%05/30/19 - Final Decision and Order; Notice of Entry5/30/2019Also found at https://www.spglobal.com/https://www.spglobal.com/marketintelligence/en/news-insights/trending/ffajrh9cmnZWXtI0Kei5Qw2
Apr 16 2018Ameren IllinoisAmeren Corp.ElectricIllinoisClosed18-0807Ameren_Illinois--Illinois_CC--Elec--April_2018--[18-0807]Rate MAP-P Modernization Action Plan - Pricing Annual Update Filing - Petition, Appendix A8.694% 8.69%

Therefore, applying this formula, the ROE is 8.69%. The 260 calculations of the 2017 average Treasury yield and the resulting ROE can be found on 261 Schedules FR D-1 and D-2.

8.69%Final Order - Final Order11/1/2018N/A
Apr 16 2018Commonwealth Edison Co.Exelon Corp.ElectricIllinoisClosed18-0808Com_Ed--Illinois_CC--Elec--April_2018--[18-0808]Annual formula rate update and revenue requirement reconciliation under Section 16-108.5 of the Public Utilities Act - Petition8.69% 8.69%

ComEd asserts that its total allowed ROE is 8.69%

8.69%Final Order - Final Order12/4/2018N/A
Apr 13 2018Columbia Gas of Maryland IncNiSource Inc.Natural GasMarylandOpen9480Columbia_Gas_Maryland--Maryland_PSC--NG--April_2018--[9480]Columbia Gas of Maryland, Inc. - an Application for Authority to Increase Rates and Charges10.9% 9.70%

As part of the Application, the Company proposed an overall rate of return of 7.998% (based on a return on equity (“ROE”) of 10.90%),

9.70%Public Utility Law Judge Division - Proposed Order. Case No. 9480. (ML 222363)10/2/2018N/A
Mar 30 2018Vectren Energy Delivery OhioVectren Corp.Natural GasOhioOpen18-0298-GA-AIRVectren_Energy--Ohio_PUC--NG--March_2018--[18-0298-GA-AIR]In the Matter of the Notice of Intent to File an Application for an Increase in Gas Rates electronically filed by Mr. Andrew J Campbell on behalf of Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio.10.75%

Vectren requested a base rate increase to $34.02 million and a rate of return of 7.97%, which incorporated a return on equity (“ROE”) of 10.75%

N/AN/AN/AFinal Order and external sources provide final ROR, not ROE
Mar 29 2018Appalachian Power Co.American Electric PowerElectricVirginiaClosedPUR-2018-00018Appalachian_Power--Virginia_SCC--Elec--March_2018--[PUR-2018-00018]Appalachian Power Company - Petition for approval of a rate adjustment clause and Request for Waiver.10.4% 10.40%

APCo proposes an annual revenue @5 requirement for the 12 months ending February 29,2020, of A approximately $28.6 million, which the Company calculated using ^ a return on equity of 10.4%.

10.40%Appalachian Power Company - Final Order - 1/2/191/2/2019N/A
Mar 29 2018PECO Energy Co.Exelon Corp.ElectricPennsylvaniaOpenR-2018-3000164PECO_Energy--Pennsylvania_PUC--Elec--March_2018--[2018-3000164]Rate Increase Filing - PECO Energy10.95%

The requestedr ates would produce a 7.79% return on the Company’s claimed measures of value and are turn on its common equity of 10.95%. These return levels are recommended by Mr. Paul R. Moul (PECOStatementNo.5), the Company’s cost-of-capital consultant and an expert on the subject of rate of return.

N/AExelon Reports Fourth Quarter and Full Year 2018 Results and Initiates 2019 Financial Outlook12/20/2018FOUND at exeloncorp.com
Mar 19 2018Virginia Electric & Power Co.Dominion Energy Inc.ElectricVirginiaOpenPUR-2018-00042Virginia_Electric_Power--Virginia_SCC--Elec--March_2018--[PUR-2018-00042]Application for revision of a rate adjustment clause: Rider U9.2% 9.20%

for purposes of calculating the revenue requirement for the February 1, 2019 through January 31, 2020 Rate Year in this case, the Company used an ROE of 9.2%

9.20%Virginia Sets New ROE for Electric Rate Adjustment Clauses4/1/2018FOUND at powerprofit.fortnightly.com
Mar 16 2018Columbia Gas of PennsylvaniaNiSource Inc.Natural GasPennsylvaniaOpenM-2018-2641242Columbia_Gas_Pennsylvania--Pennsylvania_PUC--NG--March_2018--[M-2018-2641242]Secretarial Letter for TCJA 2017 Final11.25%

If approved, the requested distribution rate increase will move UGI Electric’s inadequatereturn on equity from an estimated 6.65% for the 12-month period ended September 30, 2017, toan allowed 11.25% for the FPFTY.

Opinion and Order - 3000124-OSA - 12-20-18 PM - Exceptions to RD - PA PUC et al v Duquesne - General Rate Case Partial Settlement12/20/2018N/A
Mar 15 2018CenterPoint Energy ResourcesCenterPoint Energy Inc.Natural GasOklahomaOpenPUD-201800029CenterPoint_Energy--Oklahoma_CC--NG--March_2018--[PUD-201800029]Document Number 3005185410% 9.5-10.5%

The PBRC Plan provides that for purposes of any Annual Performance BasedRate Change, the Company’s Allowed Return on Equity (“AR”) should be 10.00 percent.

9.5-10.5%Document Number 3014292410/4/2018PERFORMANCE BASED RATE CHANGE (PBRC) PLAN
Feb 15 2018Portland General Electric Co.Portland General Electric Co.ElectricOregonAcknowledgedUE-335Portland_General_Electric--Oregon_PUC--Elec--Feb_2018--[UE-335]INITIAL UTILITY FILING - PGE GENERAL RATE REVISION9.5% 9.50%

We are proposing a 9.5% ROE consistent 13with the final result in UE 319

9.50%TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS - PGE GENERAL RATE REVISION8/16/2018* This docket is a contested case.
Feb 15 2018Chattanooga Gas CompanySouthern Co.Natural GasTennesseeClosed1800017Chattanooga_Gas--Tennessee_RA--NG--Feb_2018--[1800017]Petition11.25% 9.80%

The Company proposes an ROE of 11.25% per annum.

9.80%Amended Order1/15/2019Attrition period: 12months ending on 6/30/19
Jan 31 2018Ameren IllinoisAmeren Corp.Natural GasIllinoisClosed18-0463Ameren_Illinois-Illinois-CC-NG-Jan_2018-[18-0463](PART 1) 285 Filing (Tariffs, Testimony)9.87% 9.87%

Specifically, the Orderapproves the Stipulations’ proposed return on equity of 9.87%

9.87%Memorandum to the Commission - Memorandum to the Commission11/1/2018Test year ending on 12/31/1912/24/18: Commission to take action on new rates
Jan 26 2018Orange & Rockland Utlts Inc.Consolidated Edison Inc.ElectricNew YorkOpen18-E-0067Orange_Rockland_Utlts--New_York-PSC--Elec--Jan_2018--[18-E-0067]O&R Electric Rate Case Filing 012618-Orange and Rockland Utilities, Inc.-18-E-00679.75% 9%9.75%Policy Panel Testimony OR2018 EG-New York State Department of Public Service-18-E-0067

Company’s request for a 9.75 percent return on equity,

9%Order Adopting Terms of Joint Proposal and Establishing Electric and Gas Rate Plans-Public Service Commission-18-G-00683/14/2019N/A
Jan 26 2018Orange & Rockland Utlts Inc.Consolidated Edison Inc.Natural GasNew YorkOpen18-G-0068Orange_Rockland_Utlts--New_York-PSC--NG--Jan_2018--[18-G-0068]Application9.75% 9%

The Company has included a 9.75% return on equity (ROE)

9%Order Adopting Terms of Joint Proposal and Establishing Electric and Gas Rate Plans-Public Service Commission-18-G-00683/14/2019Issued and Effective: March 14, 2019
Jan 12 2018Public Service Electric GasPublic Service Enterprise Group Inc.ElectricNew JerseyClosedER18010029Public_Service_Electric--NJ_BPU--Elec--Jan_2018--[ER18010029]Board Orders - ER18010029 - 1-31-18-IIA10.1% 9.60%

The requested Return on Equity (“ROE”) in the filing was 10.10%

9.60%Board Orders - ER18010029 - 10-29-18-2K29 Oct, 2018N/A
Jan 12 2018Public Service Electric GasPublic Service Enterprise Group Inc.Natural GasNew JerseyOpenER18010029Public_Service_Electric--NJ_BPU--NG--Jan_2018--[GR18010029]Board Orders - ER18010029 - 10-29-18-2K10.1% 9.60%

The requested Return on Equity (“ROE”) in the filing was 10.10%

9.60%PSEG Investor Fact Book2018FOUND at https://investor.pseg.com
2017 AND EARLIER
Dec 15 2017Black Hills Energy ArkansasBlack Hills Corp.Natural GasArkansasOpen17-071-UBlack_Hills_Energy_Arkansas--Arkansas_PSC--NG--Dec_2017--[17-071-U]Black Hills Energy Arkansas, Inc. submits Motion for Interim Protective Order. Establishes Docket. Ks10.2% 9.61%

BHEA requests a return on equity (ROE) of 10.2 percent

9.61%Exhibit H.18b - PSC - Quarterly Rate Case Report for quarter ending 12-31-20185/10/2019FOUND at http://www.arkleg.state.ar.us/
Nov 17 2017Pacific Gas and Electric Co.PG&E Corp.Natural GasCaliforniaReopenedA1711009Pacific_Gas_Electric--California_PUC--NG--Nov_2017--[A1711009]Application filed by PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY on 11/17/2017 Conf# 114700 (Attachment2)10.25% 10.40%

The proposal will also boost PG&E’s return on equity (ROE) to 16 percent from 10.25 percent, the company said.

10.40%2017 Joint AnnualReport to Shareholders2017FOUND at http://www.pgecorp.com
Nov 8 2017Northern States Power Co.Xcel Energy Inc.TransmissionMinnesotaOpenM-17-797Northern_States_Power--Minnesota_PUC--Nov_2017--[M-17-797]Xcel Energy Initial Filing - Transmission Cost Recovery Rider Petition9.06% 9.06%

For these reasons, the Commission will set the ROE at 9.06%. This ROE is anchored in the DCF analyses, which provide a range of reasonable ROE

9.06% [Transmission]
Oct 31 2017Consumers Energy CompanyCMS EnergyNatural GasMichiganOpenU-18424Consumers_Energy--Michigan_PSC--NG--Aug_2017--[U-18424]Application, Proposed Notice of Hearing, Proposed Protective Order, and Proof of Service10.5% 10%

The Company is requesting an ROE of 10.50% in this case 2 Consumers Energy dividends to the parent as a total company.

10%U-18424-0343 Approves a settlement agreement
Oct 13 2017Minnesota Energy ResourcesWEC Energy Group Inc.Natural GasMinnesotaOpen17-563Minnesota_Energy--Minnesota_PUC--NG--Oct_2017--[17-563]MINNESOTA ENERGY RESOURCES CORPORATION-INITIAL FILING--VOLUME 1 - TABLE OF CONTENTS-17-56310.3% 9.70%

The Company is asking for a $12.6 million annual increase in its Minnesota retail natural gas rates or approximately 5.05 percent overall, effective January 1, 2018, based on a rate of return on common equity capital of 10.3 percent

9.70%PUC-ORDER--FINDINGS OF FACT, CONCLUSIONS,AND ORDER-GR-17-56326 Dec, 2018
Oct 12 2017Maui Electric Company LtdHawaiian Electric Industries Inc.ElectricHawaiiClosed2017-0150Maui_Electric--Hawaii_PUC--Elec--Oct_2017--[2017-0150]Maui Electric Company, Limited; Notice of Intent10.609% 9.50%

According to MECO. tbe requested increase is based on fuel oil prices in 2017. eusung depreciation rates, and an 8.059 rate of remra. inclusive), to-wit: on which incorporates a return on common equity of 10 609,

9.50%DECISION AND ORDER NO. 36219; Maui Electric Company, Limited; Docket No. 2017-01503/18/2019
Oct 6 2017San Diego Gas & Electric Co.Sempra EnergyElectricCaliforniaRe-openedA1710007San_Diego_Gas_Electric--California_PUC--Elec--Oct_2017--[A1710007]Application filed by San Diego Gas & Electric Company on 10/06/201710.05% 10.20%

The TY 2019 revenues at Proposed Rates reflect an authorized rate of return of 7.34% 23 based on 10.05% return on equity (ROE).5

10.20%A1710007-SDG&E-Hom-Ch 42-2 Summary of Earnings4/7/2018
Oct 6 2017San Diego Gas & Electric Co.Sempra EnergyNatural GasCaliforniaRe-openedA1710007San_Diego_Gas_Electric--California_PUC--NG--Oct_2017--[A1710007]Application filed by San Diego Gas & Electric Company on 10/06/201710.05% 10.20%

The TY 2019 revenues at Proposed Rates reflect an authorized rate of return of 7.34% 23 based on 10.05% return on equity (ROE).6

10.20%A1710007-SDG&E-Hom-Ch 42-2 Summary of Earnings4/7/2018
Oct 6 2017Southern California Gas Co.Sempra EnergyNatural GasCaliforniaRe-openedA1710008Southern_California_Gas--California_PUC--NG--Oct_2017--[A1710008]Application filed by Southern California Gas Company on 10/06/2017 Conf# 1133119.84% 10.05%

As thoroughly addressed in the Company’s Initial Brief, the overwhelming record evidence supports the stipulated return on equity (ROE)of 9.84 percent t

10.05%SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA GAS COMPANY (U 904 G) PREPARED DIRECT TESTIMONY OF RICARDO GONZALEZ (AUTHORIZED CAPITAL STRUCTURE)4/1/2019FOUND at https://www.socalgas.com
Sep 14 2017Pacific Gas and Electric Co.PG&E Corp.Natural GasCaliforniaClosedA1709006Application filed by Pacific Gas and Electric Co. on 09/14/2017N/A

N/A

Aug 21 2017Southwestern Public Service CoXcel Energy Inc.ElectricTexasInactive47527Southwestern_Public_Service--Texas_PUC--Aug_2017--[47527]SOUTHWESTERN PUBLIC SERVICE COMPANY - APPLICATION OF SOUTHWESTERN PUBLIC SERVICE COMPANY FOR AUTHORITY TO CHANGE RATES10.25% 9.50%

SPS seeks a Return on Equity (ROE) of 10.25%

9.50%PUC OPDM - FINAL ORDER12/10/2018
Aug 17 2017Delmarva Power & Light Co.Exelon Corp.Natural GasConnecticutOpen17-0978Delmarva_Power--Delaware_PSC--NG--Aug_2017 [17-0978]Filing Cover Sheet, Cover Letter & Application10.1% 9.90%

Delmarva seeks: (a) approval of an increase in gas delivery base rates of $12.866.033 or 8.8% of total revenues: and (b) approval of a return on equity of 10.10%.

9.90%Earnings Conference Call 2 nd Quarter 20188/2/2018FOUND at https://www.exeloncorp.com